Should
politicians of a particular race and religion only, represent their
specific community? What about the best man (or woman) for the job?
Many
people wrongly assume that the marginalisation of the Indians happened
during former prime minister, Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s era. Actually,
marginalisation occurred during British rule.
The Malays benefited from colonial patronage. The Chinese exploited
their business and social networks, whilst the Indians were merely seen
as a source of cheap labour in plantations and construction sites.
Then
came the race riots of 1969 and the ensuing bumiputera politics placed
Indians at a disadvantage both in education and work opportunities.
In
1971, the New Economic Policy (NEP) was formulated to correct the Malay
imbalance in the economy, British-owned corporations were taken over by
government-linked-companies (GLC) like Pernas and Permodalan Nasional
Berhad (PNB)
Later on, in the 1980s, many roads did lead to Mahathir’s doorstep.
Keen
to industrialise Malaysia, and buoyed by affirmative action policies,
the bumiputera agenda and the National Civics Bureau (BTN), he failed to
make any provision for the Indians.
So,
when rubber plantations were converted into housing estates and golf
courses, many displaced estate workers drifted to urban areas to form
Indian ghettos which became hot-beds of crime.
Decades later, the
Indian community still bore the consequences of the displacement.
Despite the failure of the NEP, with handouts making the Malays less
competitive, local university places and scholarships were still awarded
under a racial quota system. How fair is that?
In 2011, the then-MIC deputy president, Dr S Subramaniam,
claimed that 45 percent of the country's crimes involved Indians and
they were ashamed of their community as they were looked down on by the
other races.
It was not just the high crime rate amongst Indians that needed a solution, because many Indians have no birth certificates or identity cards, and were stateless.
Many Tamil schools were in a deplorable state, sited on illegal land and lacked funding.
Several
Hindu temples were also sited on land whose owners did not have a land
title. This was the allegation that was made when the caretaker Kedah
Menteri Besar Muhammad Sanusi Mohd Nor, demolished several old Hindu temples, which had significant historical attachment and cultural identity.
When reading the newspapers, one cannot escape the observation that many Indians died whilst under police custody.
Performing poorly due to marginalisation
There
would have been reports to say the victims died a sudden death; but no
one believes that lie any more. So, where is the political will to
resolve this disgraceful occurrence?
Today, the Indian community
has progressed from mainly plantation workers to one consisting of
entrepreneurs, intellectuals and professionals who form the bulk of the
country’s top lawyers and doctors.
Conversely, the other end of
the social spectrum, comprises Indians who lack confidence and are
failures. They are the ones who need our help.
However, the Indian
“problem” is exacerbated because of the lack of interaction between the
super-elite Indians, the well-to-do Indian middle class and the Indian
working underclass.
The marginalisation of working-class Indians
is reflected in their poor performance in business, equity ownership and
employment in professional sectors and the civil service.
Sadly,
our race relations still paint an unflattering, stereotypical image of
Indians in Malaysia, in much the same way people generalise with
comments like “Malays are lazy, or Chinese are greedy”.
Indians are continually let down by our politicians, who use them as a “political football”, for their own means and to fulfil their own agendas.
Hence,
many Indians are in a bind and have resigned themselves to their
plight. Discontent continues to simmer within the community.
Malaysia cannot afford to alienate its Indians.
If we want to be rid of race-based parties, then when will politicians learn how to take care of their diverse electorate?
It’s all very well to say, “Anak Melayu, anak Cina, anak India, anak Kadazan, anak Iban, semua anak saya” (all Malaysians are my children regardless of race) but the slogan means nothing when quotas (10) remain.
Whilst
we do not expect the abolition of quotas to happen overnight, most of
us would like to know when Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, will start the
dialogue to dismantle the quota system.
Issues affecting the Indian community are not just an Indian problem. It is a Malaysian problem (11). What happens to our fellow Indians, will affect both the Malays and Chinese.