Murray Hunter : Too be sure, no one can safely predict the actual outcome of the
Johor State election. There are too many factors involved. However, the
nominations last Saturday provide UMNO with a great electoral advantage.
After Johor is Negeri Sembilan which is currently ruled by a minority
Pakatan Harapan government, after UMNO withdrew support. Negeri Sembilan
will be a very fair test of voter sentiment within the southern half of
the peninsula.The crucial question that will be answered in the
coming two state elections will be if PH and UMNO are better off running
solo. Secondly the two state elections will show the DAP what options
the party really has. Will their disaster in Sabah be repeated is the
crucial test for them.
There have been many signs that major
political parties will change alliances, based upon the Johor and Negeri
Sembilan results. We have already seen PAS calling for voters to choose
UMNO, if PAS is not running a candidate in the seat during the Johor
campaign.
Johor will also test the one month old Bersama Party led
by ex-PKR deputy president Rafizi Ramli. They are presently an unknown
quantity. Bersama is contesting 15 seats in Johor.
The key to
watch in Johor is whether UMNO can do better than the 40 seats it had in
the last assembly, and whether Bersama can be taken seriously.
So, what will the next federal parliament look like?
To answer this question this far out, requires some assumptions and guess work based upon trends that can be observed.
Its
most likely that PAS could win up to 50 seats, cannibalizing seats from
Bersatu. Some Bersatu seats were lent to Bersatu for GE15 and PAS wants
them back. Amanah could also be eaten up in the coming election, some
of their seats going back to PAS.
PH is in a quandary. Many
activities that have made PH unpopular actually were undertaken by rogue
parts of the bureaucracy. However, PH will most likely pay for these
activities electorally. This is going to leave the DAP with fewer seats,
maybe with some going to the new Bersama party. PKR’s own electoral
research tells the story, unless something drastic happens.
UMNO
is a big question mark, which Johor, Negeri Sembilan, and Melaka will
answer. If UMNO does well in the south of the Peninsula, this could mean
that in a general election that UMNO could win up to 40-50 seats,
particularly if Bersatu performs poorly. Hamzah’s new movement is an
unknown.
Who will form the next government?
If
the voting scenario above occurs, PAS will be in the best position to
form a government in coalition with other parties. The most obvious is
UMNO (Barisan Nasional). This could give this grouping somewhere close
to 100 seats.
The remains of PKR, which could be around a dozen seats could allow PAS/PN to have a simple majority.
Its
well known that Ahmad Zahid Hamidi wants to take up the mantle of being
PM. However, many dismiss this for a number of reasons (proficiency in
English, etc.). Anwar could with agreement of PAS and UMNO take on a
second term, although its more likely he may take on a position as a
mentor-minister. There are other scenarios which are best to explain
later.
The ‘deep state’ elements want an UMNO controlled
government. Otherwise, a government with UMNO playing a powerful role.
However, there is a group of ‘professionals’ within PAS that want to rid
the government of such artifacts. They want to ‘save Malaysia’ and
bring back good governance. The more conservative grouping in PAS want
to play a ‘backroom role’ in any future government.
Under such as
scenario, the DAP and the small number of seats Bersama may win will be
banished to the opposition benches in parliament and not heard from.
One
can expect that most Sabah MPs in the two blocks Wawasan and GRS will
support the new government in exchange for positions and conditions. GPS
will decide on what is best for Sarawak.
This scenario has a high
possibility looking at the political environment now. After the Johor
state election this scenario could be re-evaluated as to its potential
reality.